Simmer Pots vs. Candles: What's the Difference?
How simmer pots and candles compare on ingredients, scent, safety, air, and cost, and why Maria made the switch from candles to simmer pots.
By Maria Zarate · 2 min read
Candles and simmer pots both make a house smell good, but they get there in very different ways. Here's how they compare.

Ingredients and scent
Simmer pots use fresh or dried fruit, herbs, and spices, like citrus, cinnamon, and rosemary. The scent is natural and subtle, the smell of the botanicals themselves.
Candles are usually made of wax infused with fragrance oils, either synthetic or essential oil. They release a stronger, more concentrated scent right away.
Flame and safety
A candle needs an open flame and burning wax. That's a fire hazard, and it needs constant supervision.
A simmer pot sits on the stove or in a slow cooker, with no open flame. It still needs watching: keep the water topped up so it doesn't boil dry.
Air and humidity
A simmer pot gives off steam as it heats, so it adds a little moisture to dry indoor air as well as scent.
A candle doesn't add moisture. Depending on the materials and how long it burns, traditional wax can also give off some soot or particles.
Reuse and cost
A candle burns down and it's gone. Simmer pot ingredients can be reused. One Sage & Spice bag is good for 2 to 3 uses: strain it after each use, freeze it in a zip-top bag, and add it to fresh water next time. Maria likes to add a few slices of fresh citrus each time.
Why Maria switched
Maria cut candles and sprays out of her own home. Many candles are made with ingredients she doesn't want in her house, around people, pets, or even houseplants. You can read more of her story on the about page.
Which one to choose
| Simmer pot | Candle | |
|---|---|---|
| Made from | Fruit, herbs, spices, and natural extracts | Wax and fragrance oil |
| Scent | Natural and subtle | Strong and concentrated |
| Flame | None | Open flame |
| Adds moisture | Yes, from the steam | No |
| Reusable | 2 to 3 uses per bag | Gone once burned |
If you want a natural scent from real ingredients, a simmer pot is the way to go. New to them? Start with what a simmer pot is or how to use one.
Questions
Is a simmer pot safer than a candle?
A simmer pot has no open flame, so there's no burning wax. It still needs watching, because the water level has to be kept up so the pot doesn't boil dry.
Does a simmer pot smell as strong as a candle?
Usually not. A simmer pot gives a natural, subtle botanical scent. Candles with fragrance oils release a stronger, more concentrated scent right away.
Can I reuse a simmer pot?
Yes. One bag is good for 2 to 3 uses. Strain out the ingredients after each use, freeze them in a zip-top bag, and add them to fresh water next time. A candle is gone once it burns down.



